• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Catholic Review

Catholic Review

Inspiring the Archdiocese of Baltimore

Menu
  • Home
  • News
        • Local News
        • World News
        • Vatican News
        • Obituaries
        • Featured Video
        • En Español
        • Sports News
        • Official Clergy Assignments
        • Schools News
  • Commentary
        • Contributors
          • Question Corner
          • George Weigel
          • Elizabeth Scalia
          • Michael R. Heinlein
          • Effie Caldarola
          • Guest Commentary
        • CR Columnists
          • Archbishop William E. Lori
          • Rita Buettner
          • Christopher Gunty
          • George Matysek Jr.
          • Mark Viviano
          • Father Joseph Breighner
          • Father Collin Poston
          • Amen Columns
  • Entertainment
        • Events
        • Movie & Television Reviews
        • Arts & Culture
        • Books
        • Recipes
        • CR Kids
  • About Us
        • Contact Us
        • Our History
        • Meet Our Staff
        • Photos to own
        • Shop
        • CR Media platforms
        • Electronic Edition
        • Subscribe
  • Advertising
  • Kids
  • News Tips
  • Radio/Podcasts
        • Catholic Review Radio
        • Protagonistas de Fe
        • In God’s Image
        • “In Charity and Truth” with Archbishop William E. Lori
  • Subscribe
Demonstrators hold signs protesting capital punishment in front of the U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington June 29, 2022. (OSV News photo/Kevin Lamarque, Reuters)

Capital punishment is ambiguously inadmissible

October 12, 2026
By Kenneth Craycraft
OSV News
Filed Under: Commentary, Respect Life

In late September, the state of Tennessee attempted and failed to execute Christa Pike, after 31 years in prison.

The news description of the botched execution is gruesome. Multiple attempts to inject Pike with a lethal dose of phenobarbital were “unsuccessful.” It has resulted in Pike being placed on life support (as I write this column) alive but unable to breathe on her own.

Having failed to kill her, Tennessee is now trying to keep her alive, presumably for another opportunity to kill her. Far and wide, this horrifying incident has been cited as a reason to eliminate capital punishment. It is not.

The incompetence of some officials to carry out a law is not necessarily a sound basis for opposing the law.

Proponents of capital punishment highlight the extreme sadistic violence of the murder of which Christa Pike was convicted. Then 18 years old, along with two accomplices, Pike tortured 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer with a box cutter, meat cleaver and large chunk of asphalt, before killing her by crushing her skull. Pike removed a fragment of Slemmer’s skull, keeping it as a souvenir. The monstrous brutality of this crime has been cited as a reason to maintain capital punishment. It is not.

Visceral reaction to certain actions is not a sound basis for legislating against them. Catholic theologians must wrestle with the issue of capital punishment both on moral grounds and in the context of the development of doctrine. Neither the moral status nor the history of the Church’s position is as clear as proponents and opponents of capital punishment would have us believe.

Advocates and supporters both make compelling arguments, but neither, in my judgment, make convincing ones. But this is not a concession to either side.

Even the Catechism of the Catholic Church is not as clear as we might like it to be. In 2018, Section 2267 of the catechism was revised to provide three rationales for why it concludes that “the death penalty is inadmissible,” and why “she works with determination for its abolition worldwide.”

First, the catechism explains that “the dignity of the person is not lost even after the commission of very serious crimes.” Certainly, this is true of what theologians call “ontological dignity.” Ontological dignity is based on the very nature of the human person as made in the image and likeness of God. As such, this dignity is not alienable, any more than any other aspect of human nature can be repudiated.

But theologians also cite “moral dignity.” This describes the relative exercise of moral agency. It can be impaired or even lost when a person makes moral choices against the good of the person and society.

This is why we can morally deprive a person of property or liberty when that person commits offenses against society. But, again, no such commission, regardless of the severity, can compromise ontological dignity. I wish Section 2267 of the catechism had made this distinction between ontological and moral dignity. It did not.

The second reason to oppose capital punishment, the catechism explains, is the emergence of “a new understanding … of the significance of penal sanctions imposed by the state.” It is not clear what this means, but I have interpreted it as a warning against giving the state the power to kill in cold blood. And whether one opposes or favors capital punishment, there’s no denial that it is dispassionate, cold-blooded, killing.

Finally, the catechism cites “more effective systems of detention, … which ensure the due protection of citizens,” but which do not “definitively deprive the guilty of the possibility of redemption.” Of the three reasons for its conclusion that capital punishment is inadmissible, this is the most contentious. It seems to imply that the admissibility of capital punishment is contingent upon such “effective systems of detention.”

But what about societies where such systems do not exist? Some read this provision as implying that the prohibition of the death penalty is conditional, not absolute. It is not an unreasonable interpretation. I wish the Catechism were clearer on this point. It is not.

I believe that Pope Francis, who implemented the revised language of Section 2267 of the catechism, was categorically opposed to capital punishment. And I think he intended Section 2267 to teach that capital punishment is morally prohibited, without exception. It does not.

My opposition to capital punishment is much closer to absolute than many colleagues and other faithful Catholics. If limited to the United States and similarly advanced countries, my opposition is, in fact, absolute. But I acknowledge that the ambiguity of the language of Section 2267 does not require every Catholic to agree. I wish it did. It does not.

Read more commentary

Question Corner: Is it OK to have Mass said for deceased people who are not Catholic?

‘Vain repetition?’ Nah, the rosary can be endlessly varied

The view of a school bus from the driver's seat in a car, with the car's side mirror included in the image

The children at the bus stop (and the passage of time)

Question Corner: Why does the Church allow pieces of a saint’s body to be distributed for relics?

“Contextuality” (with apologies to Irving Berlin)

White Martyr Family

Copyright © 2026 OSV News

Print Print

Primary Sidebar

Kenneth Craycraft

View all posts from this author

| Recent Commentary |

Question Corner: Is it OK to have Mass said for deceased people who are not Catholic?

‘Vain repetition?’ Nah, the rosary can be endlessly varied

The view of a school bus from the driver's seat in a car, with the car's side mirror included in the image

The children at the bus stop (and the passage of time)

Question Corner: Why does the Church allow pieces of a saint’s body to be distributed for relics?

“Contextuality” (with apologies to Irving Berlin)

| Recent Local News |

Father Michael Sergi, former longtime Baltimore pastor, dies at 73

Archbishop Lori sees inspiration and fraternity at U.S. bishops’ meeting 

One student’s question sparks a special needs ministry at St. Joseph in Eldersburg

5 Things to Know about the 106th Turkey Bowl

USCCB president encourages bishops to be aware of blind spots

| Catholic Review Radio |

Footer

Our Vision

Real Life. Real Faith. 

Catholic Review Media communicates the Gospel and its impact on people’s lives in the Archdiocese of Baltimore and beyond.

Our Mission

Catholic Review Media provides intergenerational communications that inform, teach, inspire and engage Catholics and all of good will in the mission of Christ through diverse forms of media.

Contact

Catholic Review
320 Cathedral Street
Baltimore, MD 21201
443-524-3150
mail@CatholicReview.org

 

Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Recent

  • Question Corner: Is it OK to have Mass said for deceased people who are not Catholic?
  • Father Michael Sergi, former longtime Baltimore pastor, dies at 73
  • US Catholic bishops approve annual day of prayer for racial justice
  • Austrian bishops sound alarm as the country sees 267% surge in assisted suicide in 3 years
  • Humans must remain in control of AI, says bishop
  • A year after special immigration message, concerns still relevant, USCCB migration chair says
  • Archbishop Lori sees inspiration and fraternity at U.S. bishops’ meeting 
  • Start at home, revive young people’s hope in love to foster marriage, say 2 US bishops
  • US bishops focus on building ‘construction sites of hope,’ elect leaders in fall assembly session

Search

Membership

Catholic Media Assocation

Maryland-Delaware-DC Press Association

The Associated Church Press

© 2026 CATHOLIC REVIEW MEDIA, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED