Catholic leaders welcome move to ditch ‘Maryland, My Maryland’

After decades of criticism for its unabashed support of the Confederacy, “Maryland, My Maryland” is closer than ever to being removed as the official song of the Free State.

The State Senate voted unanimously March 19 in favor of getting rid of the controversial song after the House of Delegates voted 94-38 to do the same earlier this month.

The legislation now moves to the desk of Republican Gov. Larry Hogan Jr., who has not indicated his position on the bill.

A Baltimore-born Catholic named James Ryder Randall was inspired to write the poem that would eventually become the state song after the professor of literature at Poydras College in Pointe-Coupee, La., read a newspaper report about the Pratt Street Riot in Baltimore in 1861. The violence erupted after an angry mob of pro-Southern Baltimoreans hurled paving stones, bottles and rocks at soldiers from the Sixth Massachusetts Regiment that was traveling through the city on its way to defend Washington, D.C. at the outset of the Civil War.

Several civilians were wounded or killed during the melee, including one of Randall’s friends. It is considered the first blood spilled in the Civil War.

The poem’s verses refer to newly elected President Abraham Lincoln as a “tyrant” and a “despot.” They violently encourage Maryland to “avenge the patriotic gore that flecked the streets of Baltimore” and refer to the Union as “Northern scum.”

Father Raymond Harris, pastor of Holy Family in Randallstown and a member of Archbishop William E. Lori’s working group on racism, said he can’t understand why any Marylander today would want to sing a song that celebrates the Confederacy.

“Part of dealing with racism and reconciliation is that we must deal with the truth,” Father Harris said, “and part of the truth of the Confederacy was that it was raised up to perpetuate the institution of slavery as part of the economy and it treated enslaved peoples as commodities. To continue to celebrate that in song is really against the dignity of human beings.”

Father Harris said there is a need to embrace national unity.

“The Civil War is over,” he said.

Jenny Kraska, executive director of the Maryland Catholic Conference, legislative lobbying arm of the state’s bishops, said the move by lawmakers “reflects an awareness of the pain and impact that words have.”

“In his pastoral letter, ‘Journey to Racial Justice’ (published in 2019), Archbishop Lori calls for us as Catholics to make an ‘honest examination’ of our own past,” she said. “We see the General Assembly doing that as a legislative body, and seeking to end the pain caused by the lyrics of this Civil War-era song.”

Quoting the U.S. bishops’ 2018 letter against racism, “Open Wide Our Hearts,” Kraska said the vote is an example of “conversion of heart, a conversion that will compel change, and the reform of our institutions and society.”

There have been numerous efforts going back to the 1970s to remove “Maryland, My Maryland” as the state song, but none has come this far.

Set to the tune used in the Christmas song, “O Tannenbaum” (“O Christmas Tree”), the song wasn’t officially adopted until 1939.

In written testimony submitted in favor of the legislation to remove the song, Edward Papenfuse, a former archivist for the state, noted that Republican Gov. Harry Nice vetoed legislation to make “Maryland, My Maryland” the state song. The General Assembly passed the bill again and Democratic Gov. Herbert O’Conor ultimately signed it into law.

Papenfuse said the song has been labeled the “Marseillaise of the Confederacy” and was sung by soldiers charged with defending the institution of slavery. In addition to stirring sectional prejudice, Papenfuse said Randall’s words glorify the actions of the mob.

“They enshrine a world in which slavery was considered righteous and mob violence a virtue,” he said.

Few people voiced public opposition to striking the song from official status. In written testimony against the bill, however, Terry M. Klima of Perry Hall, commander of the Maryland Sons of Confederate Veterans, said the song was popular in Maryland before 1939 and was showcased along with “The Star-Spangled Banner” at Maryland’s exhibition at the 1915 Panama Pacific International Exposition.

“The State of Maryland even commissioned the issuance of a commemorative coin for this event, featuring the likeness of James Ryder Randall and Francis Scott Key and the titles of their works,” Klima wrote.

Following the Pratt Street Riot, Lincoln put parts of Maryland under martial law and suspended habeas corpus. During the Civil War, some journalists who sided with the Confederacy were arrested. Among them were Michael J. Kelly and John B. Piet, publishers of The Catholic Mirror (predecessor to the Catholic Review) who were twice arrested for printing works of a “treasonable character.” They were detained at Fort McHenry during one of those arrests.

“Rather than a clarion call to join the Confederacy, many view the song as a reminder of the indignities Maryland suffered when the protections afforded U.S. citizens under the Constitution were not upheld,” Klima wrote.

Father Donald Sterling, pastor of New All Saints in Liberty Heights and a member of Archbishop Lori’s working group on racism, said it’s time for Maryland to adopt a new song.

“I think something different needs to be drafted that is inclusive and acknowledges the mistakes that have been made as we move toward unity,” said Father Sterling, suggesting that it would be “conceptually interesting” to show in song that Maryland is “all-inclusive.”

Several alternatives to “Maryland, My Maryland” have been proposed, including one composed by two staff members and a former student of DeMatha Catholic High School in Hyattsville. Democratic U.S. Representative Jamie B. Raskin has also offered his own version.

Email George Matysek at gmatysek@CatholicReview.org

Also see

Our heart of darkness

Dean of Georgetown Law says interim U.S. attorney’s DEI threat attacks its Catholic mission

Rev. King’s legacy involves ‘uniting our nation as one community of hope,’ cardinal says

Pope calls for inclusion of Romani people in the church

Archbishop Broglio: MLK challenges all to ‘live out’ solidarity, human dignity

How Father Tolton handled travails, transitions is model for living out the faith, says bishop

Copyright © 2021 Catholic Review Media

 Print