• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Catholic Review

Catholic Review

Inspiring the Archdiocese of Baltimore

Menu
  • Home
  • News
        • Local News
        • World News
        • Vatican News
        • Obituaries
        • Featured Video
        • En Español
        • Sports News
        • Official Clergy Assignments
        • Schools News
  • Commentary
        • Contributors
          • Question Corner
          • George Weigel
          • Elizabeth Scalia
          • Michael R. Heinlein
          • Effie Caldarola
          • Guest Commentary
        • CR Columnists
          • Archbishop William E. Lori
          • Rita Buettner
          • Christopher Gunty
          • George Matysek Jr.
          • Mark Viviano
          • Father Joseph Breighner
          • Father Collin Poston
          • Robyn Barberry
          • Hanael Bianchi
          • Amen Columns
  • Entertainment
        • Events
        • Movie & Television Reviews
        • Arts & Culture
        • Books
        • Recipes
  • About Us
        • Contact Us
        • Our History
        • Meet Our Staff
        • Photos to own
        • Books/CDs/Prayer Cards
        • CR Media platforms
        • Electronic Edition
  • Advertising
  • Shop
        • Purchase Photos
        • Books/CDs/Prayer Cards
        • Magazine Subscriptions
        • Archdiocesan Directory
  • CR Radio
        • CR Radio
        • Protagonistas de Fe
  • News Tips
  • Subscribe
A file photo shows an American flag flying outside Our Lady Queen of Martyrs Church in Centerport, N.Y. (OSV News photo/Gregory A. Shemitz, Long Island Catholic)

Simone Weil on obligations, rights and the need for roots after 75 years

June 5, 2024
By Kenneth Craycraft
OSV News
Filed Under: Commentary

Share
Share on Facebook
Share
Share this
Pin
Pin this
Share
Share on LinkedIn

In my recent book, “Citizens Yet Strangers: Living Authentically Catholic in a Divided America,” I argue that Catholics should neither endorse nor use the language of individual rights. Of course, I understand that this assertion is both surprising and foreign to the American ear. We invoke our individual rights, we believe, as protections both against government overreach and intrusion into our private lives.

Indeed, for most Americans, the moral life is inconceivable apart from individual rights as the foundation of morality, upon which both private action and public policy are based. Nor, of course, does the typical Catholic see any tension between his faith and a commitment to individual rights.

My contention, however, is that possessive rights theory is the foundation of the defective moral anthropology of enlightenment liberalism as invented by 17th-century moral philosopher Thomas Hobbes. In my book, I explain that this theory of individual rights is not merely incompatible with the Christian doctrines of solidarity and common good, but contradictory to them.

This is because rights language is the expression of Hobbes’ “state of nature,” which is a “war of every man against every man.” Put another way, rights language is the moral expression that we are all naturally enemies of one another. Thus, when we assert our rights on the one hand, we perpetuate the very disharmony and conflict that we bemoan on the other.

Of course, alert readers will reply that magisterial documents are replete with rights language. Papal and other official writings often invoke a theory of rights as compatible with, and even derived from, Catholic moral theology. Even beloved Popes St. John Paul II and Benedict XVI often referred to rights of various kinds. Read carefully, however, these invocations of rights do not refer to rights as a foundational moral category. Rather, they use rights to describe logical corollaries of fundamental Catholic moral categories of dignity, duty and common good.

For example, the landmark Declaration on Religious Freedom, “Dignitatis Humanae” from the Second Vatican Council “declares that the human person has a right to religious freedom.” But rather than invoke this right as a basic moral category, “Dignitatis” quickly explains that it is itself based on the “dignity of the human person as … revealed [by] the word of God.” Thus, religious freedom must be recognized not as a natural right in a mythical state of nature, but rather as a “civil right” derived from the duty of governments to protect human dignity. Put another way, man has a duty to worship God; governments have an obligation to protect this duty through political and legal measures. The phrase that we use to describe this immunity is “civic rights.”

This understanding of rights as derivative of duties and obligations is far less problematic than liberalism’s theory of rights as the basis of all moral life. Indeed, while the word is the same, the meaning is completely different. Unfortunately, however, we Americans are ill-equipped to see the distinction or to understand rights language as expressing anything other than individual possessive claims against one another in a war of all against all.

A useful antidote to this malady is a careful reading of French philosopher Simone Weil’s profound book, “The Need for Roots,” published in France 75 years ago this year. We can both redeem the time since this publication, as well as redeem our understanding of the nature of the human person, by revisiting this remarkable work.

Weil begins “The Need for Roots” with an express discussion of rights as derivative of obligations as the foundational moral category. “The concept of obligations takes precedence over rights,” she explains. Thus, rights “are subordinate and relative to” obligations. Weil suggests, in fact, that there’s no such thing as a right other than in relation to obligation. Thus, a right is not an individual possession, as in the modern liberal theory, but rather the recognition of our mutual obligations to one another.

A right, she contends, is fulfilled when people “recognize that they have an obligation towards” others. Rights only exist as the subjective recognition of obligations. “A man alone in the world would have not rights,” she concludes, “but he would have obligations.” Obligations are unconditional; rights are conditioned upon obligations.

This short column cannot do justice to the intricacy of Weil’s important book. But that’s not my purpose. Rather, as with all columns in this space, my purpose is to introduce Catholic readers to classic works that may have been neglected or overlooked over the years. Simone Weil died at the age of 34, which makes “The Need for Roots” all the more remarkable in its erudition and insight. As Catholics, we can learn much about our own faith from reading this extraordinary work from one of the great minds of the 20th century.

Read More Commentary

Cupcakes with 2025 graduation toothpicks in them and a bowl of cookies

Our 31-hour Road Trip

St. Paul and discovering that sin is ‘missing the mark’

Six lit candles on a chocolate birthday cake

Making a birthday wish come true

Pilgrims of Hope: Walking the Way of St. Francis in the Year of Jubilee

The fisherman and the pharisee

A loaf of sliced bread

We are part of the miracle

Copyright © 2024 OSV News

Print Print

Share
Share on Facebook
Share
Share this
Pin
Pin this
Share
Share on LinkedIn

Primary Sidebar

Kenneth Craycraft

View all posts from this author

| Recent Commentary |

Cupcakes with 2025 graduation toothpicks in them and a bowl of cookies

Our 31-hour Road Trip

St. Paul and discovering that sin is ‘missing the mark’

Six lit candles on a chocolate birthday cake

Making a birthday wish come true

Pilgrims of Hope: Walking the Way of St. Francis in the Year of Jubilee

The fisherman and the pharisee

| Recent Local News |

Archbishop Lori announces clergy appointments, including pastor and associate pastors

DUAL ENROLLMENT

Double the learning: Dual enrollment provides college credit to high school students

St. Mary’s purchases former Annapolis Area Christian School

Radio Interview: Exploring the Nicene Creed – Part Two

St. Clement Mary Hofbauer adapts to times, cultures as it celebrates 100th anniversary

| Catholic Review Radio |

CatholicReview · Catholic Review Radio

Footer

Our Vision

Real Life. Real Faith. 

Catholic Review Media communicates the Gospel and its impact on people’s lives in the Archdiocese of Baltimore and beyond.

Our Mission

Catholic Review Media provides intergenerational communications that inform, teach, inspire and engage Catholics and all of good will in the mission of Christ through diverse forms of media.

Contact

Catholic Review
320 Cathedral Street
Baltimore, MD 21201
443-524-3150
mail@CatholicReview.org

 

Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Recent

  • Come away and rest awhile
  • French woman hopes sharing mystical encounter with Minnesota Benedictine helps sainthood cause
  • Pope: Vatican still ready to host peace talks between Russia, Ukraine
  • Archbishop Lori announces clergy appointments, including pastor and associate pastors
  • Pope prays for conversion of those resisting climate action at new Mass
  • Judge blocks, for now, Planned Parenthood defunding provision backed by bishops
  • ANALYSIS: ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ gives school-choice advocates partial victory with more to do
  • Notre Dame prepares to reopen towers’ tour with return of famed statues of saints to rooftop
  • After 12 years, locals welcome pope back to his summer home

Search

Membership

Catholic Media Assocation

Maryland-Delaware-DC Press Association

The Associated Church Press

© 2025 CATHOLIC REVIEW MEDIA, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

en Englishes Spanish
en en