Let’s Talk Turkey November 20, 2026By Rita Buettner Catholic Review Filed Under: Blog, Commentary, Open Window My parents have always divided the labor in the kitchen. My mother makes the pumpkin pie, the gravy, and multiple side dishes, but my father is always responsible for the turkey. By the time we arrive at my parents’ house for Thanksgiving dinner, my parents are deep in food prep, so there might not be anyone ready to greet us at the door. That’s just fine. As we open the door, we are greeted by the succulent aroma of a roasting turkey. My dad’s turkey is always excellent. And, as with most projects my father takes on, I’m not sure what his secret is. For years, I’ve seen articles and videos full of tips from people explaining how to keep turkey from drying out. They explain how to prepare it in just the right brine, or they insist that deep frying it gives the best flavor. They tell you how often to baste it and what to use as your basting liquid. They advise you on where to get your turkey, what size to buy, and how to prepare it. I’m pretty sure my father hasn’t read any of those articles. He doesn’t need to. He just knows what to do—and he does it over and over again. Maybe he has a magic touch. Maybe his mother, who was an amazing cook herself, taught him what to do. Maybe he has some secret insight from growing up in Minnesota and picking vegetables for Green Giant to pay his way through college. Whatever he does, the turkey comes out of the oven crispy on the outside, moist on the inside, and delicious throughout. As far as I can tell, my father buys the biggest turkey he can find so there will be lots of leftovers. Then he slides it into the oven at the beginning of the day, bastes it casually a few times, and lifts it out of the oven at dinnertime. Then he slices the turkey onto a couple of platters for his children to inhale and his grandchildren to gobble down or hide under the mashed potatoes on their plates. Maybe there’s a secret recipe I should be trying to learn so we can pass it down, generation after generation. But it’s hard to keep your mind on that when the house is full of that incredible aroma, and you’re so hungry from spending the day shivering and cheering at the Turkey Bowl. And there are always children to play with, adults to chat with, canned cranberry sauce to open, appetizers to prepare, and all the excitement of the Thanksgiving holiday. Who has time to be taking notes on your dad’s food prep? Clearly I haven’t. But, of course, I can be grateful for the turkey without knowing all that goes into making it a highlight of the meal. We can be sincerely thankful without knowing why or how things come to be. We don’t have to know the science behind a rainbow or a sunrise to marvel at its beauty. We don’t need to understand how God brings certain people into our lives or how a fresh orange in the darkest days of winter can be full of such sweetness. We don’t need to know how a friend knows to text or call just when you need them most, or why that homily at Mass gave you just the comfort or peace you were hoping for today. It is enough just to sit in gratitude, seeing God’s hand in those everyday encounters, and feeling the strength of his love. “The secret of happiness is to live moment by moment and to thank God for what He is sending us every day in His goodness,” St. Gianna Beretta Molla said. Whatever is on our plate this Thanksgiving, may we see God’s gifts and presence in this season and be sure of his deep and eternal love. And if you see my dad in line at the grocery store and he shares his turkey-roasting secret, please let me know. Have a blessed Thanksgiving Copyright © 2026 Catholic Review Media Print