Cardinal Fernández updates synod on study group focusing on women’s roles

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — Pope Francis decided the question of ordaining women deacons was not to be discussed at the 2024 Synod of Bishops, and he directed a synod-related study group on women’s ministries not to explore the matter, according to the Vatican’s doctrinal chief.

“We know that the Holy Father has expressed that at this time the issue of the female diaconate is not mature and has asked that we not entertain this possibility for now,” Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, told the synod Oct. 21.

However, he said, the second commission Pope Francis set up in 2020 to study women deacons “will continue to work,” and the “partial conclusions” it has reached “will be published when the time is right.”

But, the cardinal said, “the Holy Father is very concerned about the role of women in the church and, even before the synod’s request” that the matter be studied, Pope Francis “asked the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith to explore the possibilities of development without focusing on holy orders,” or diaconal ordination.

The dicastery “cannot work in a different direction,” Cardinal Fernández said, adding that he agrees with the pope “because thinking about the diaconate for some women does not solve the issue of the millions of women in the church,” who serve in hundreds of ways.

While most of what is said in the synod hall is considered confidential, the cardinal’s address to the synod was released by the Vatican just days after Cardinal Fernández apologized to synod members for not attending a meeting to discuss the work of his study group on women’s ministry.

While the cardinal had not promised to attend the meeting Oct. 18 to speak about the study group’s work, about 100 synod participants — cardinals, bishops, priests, religious and laypeople — thought he, or at least members of the group, would be there.

In a message sent to synod members after the meeting, Cardinal Fernández wrote that he had been informed of “the displeasure expressed by some members of the synod” that he was not present.

“I myself am sorry for the misunderstanding,” he said, adding that he had informed the synod Oct. 9 that he would send two dicastery staff members. However, he offered to meet Oct. 24 with synod members “to listen to their reflections and receive any written documents from them.”

According to people present at the meeting Oct. 18, participants had been visibly and vocally upset that the two people Cardinal Fernández sent were not members of the study group and that they did not plan to have a dialogue with participants.

The meeting, like discussions within the synod itself, was meant to be confidential, so participants who spoke about it asked that their names not be used.

One attendee said the frustration mostly focused on the working group’s methodology and lack of transparency, particularly that the cardinal had not identified any of the members of the group.

Following the first assembly of the synod on synodality in 2023, Pope Francis set up 10 study groups to reflect more deeply on some of the most controversial or complicated questions raised during the synod process, including the question of women’s ministry and decision-making roles in the church.

Pope Francis, in a February letter to Cardinal Mario Grech, general secretary of the synod, said, “It is important that the aforementioned study groups work according to an authentically synodal method,” with dialogue and broad participation. He asked that the groups make a preliminary report to the synod in 2024 and that they give him their final reports by June 2025.

After the leaders of the 10 groups gave brief reports to the synod Oct. 2, synod members voted to give up one of their few free afternoons to dialogue with the leaders of the study groups and the meetings were scheduled for Oct. 18.

Synod participants signed up in advance for the meetings so that the Vatican could arrange rooms for them to meet. Cardinal Fernández’ group drew the most sign-ups.

Addressing the synod Oct. 21, Cardinal Fernández said women instituted as catechists already can lead Catholic communities in the absence of a priest, but very few dioceses have taken advantage of the possibility. And only “a small percentage” of the world’s dioceses have instituted women as lectors and acolytes.

Not to mention, he said, that many dioceses have not made use of the permanent diaconate even for men and when they have, “how many times are they just ordained altar boys?”

“These couple of examples help us understand that rushing to ask for the ordination of deaconesses is not the most important way to promote women today,” the cardinal said.

“I am convinced that we can move forward step by step and arrive at very concrete things so that it is understood that there is nothing in women’s nature that prevents them from having very important roles in the leadership of the churches,” he said. “What really is coming from the Holy Spirit cannot be stopped.”

Read More Synodality

Vatican releases synod report on women’s role in Church leadership

Vatican synod study group proposes creation of pontifical commission for new technologies

Cardinal Woelki says he is finished with German Synodal Way, will skip sixth assembly

Controversial German bishop will not seek reelection as bishops’ conference president

Synod study groups release ‘interim’ reports as most continue working

Reflections on the synodal journey

Copyright © 2024 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops

 Print