Perceptions of migrants are in the political crosshairs ahead of midterms

WASHINGTON (CNS) — The political ads began appearing in early October, strategically aired a month before the November midterm elections that will determine which party will control the U.S. House of Representatives.

“This giant flood of illegal immigration is draining your paychecks, wrecking your schools, ruining your hospitals, threatening your family,” says one ad, which shows a video of migrants crossing the border or heading toward it en masse. “Mixed among the masses are drug dealers, sex traffickers and violent predators,” it continues.

Another ad proclaims: “Joe Biden is giving your money to illegal immigrants. Your kids don’t matter to him at all.”

Their aim is clear: to paint a portrait of crisis in the U.S. and draining of resources caused by migrants and the politicians who support them.   

“In recent days and weeks, we have witnessed the troubling convergence of our broken immigration system and the political divisions of our time being inflicted upon men, women, and children seeking refuge in our country,” wrote Washington Auxiliary Bishop Mario Dorsonville in an Oct. 18 reflection called “Migration and the Judgement of the Nations.”

Bishop Dorsonville — like previous chairmen of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ Committee on Migration — has been a constant voice on church teaching that calls on Catholics to welcome the stranger in an age when Catholic politicians are some of the most visible voices against that teaching.

“Reports have indicated coordinated efforts to transport migrants — and in some cases intentionally deceive them — in furtherance of outcomes that are unbecoming of a moral society,” said Bishop Dorsonville, without naming Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, both Republicans and Catholics who set the model of carting migrants by bus — and DeSantis famously by plane — dropping them off with no resources or shelter to various points around the country.

But Democrats didn’t escape Bishop Dorsonville’s reflection on how certain political actions negatively affect migrants. The bishop said the recent expansion by the Biden administration of Title 42 of the Public Health Safety Act — a policy set in motion by the Trump administration in 2020 denying asylum-seekers entry saying it was necessary to abate the coronavirus — unjustly denies “access to humanitarian protections that were enshrined in law as a response to horrors witnessed during the 20th century.”  

Neither situation, the bishop said, reflects a safe, orderly and humane immigration system.

“But their shared irreverence for human lives is all too common in our present culture,” he added.

That irreverence has amped up as each party struggles to capture control of the House of Representatives on Nov. 8 — Election Day.

Though a small group of politicians had been touting migrants as a solution to help with the country’s lingering labor shortages in the service industry and in the agricultural sector, the midterm election fight has seemed like a contest on who can be tougher on those coming into the country — legally or otherwise.

In busing migrants away from the border, politicians say they are giving others a taste of what they face in trying to accommodate border crossers in their localities.

But some say this has been done at the expense of human dignity, acting cruelly even toward children, dropped off along with their parents. These migrants have been lured onto buses with promises of food, work and help, only to find empty promises and confusion at the end of their long bus rides.     

“You’re basically dropping penniless people who don’t speak the language in an unknown city and saying, ‘Fend for yourself,'” Theresa Cardinal Brown, a managing director with the Bipartisan Policy Center, told Reuters in early October.

Images in the news and in social media of New York and Washington receiving buses full of migrants from the Republican governors, along with incendiary political ads, have driven immigration to become a top issue for voters in the upcoming election.

An Oct. 17 Harvard CAPS-Harris poll said 59% of voters said immigration is a “very important” issue in the upcoming midterms.

Even some Democrats, once known for their support of immigration and immigrants as a party, now find themselves seeking distance from that stance.

“It’s not just far-right conservatives who are blocking Democrats from changing anything (related to immigration) in Congress right now, it’s also moderate Democrats,” said Caitlin Dickerson, an immigration reporter for The Atlantic during a conference at Georgetown University’s Law Center in September.

Leading up to the midterms, Democrats have sounded a lot like Republicans on the issue.

“I’ve spent a lot of time on our southern border and let me just say it’s a mess. It’s chaos. It’s crisis after crisis,” said Arizona Democrat Sen. Mark Kelly during an Oct. 6 debate.

He touted that he had “stood up to Democrats when they’re wrong on this issue — including the president.”

While acknowledging immigration presents challenges, Bishop Dorsonville argued there is a “just path forward” to accommodate the flow of people. However, fostering misconceptions, painting migrants as burdens and mistreating them, misses out on the opportunity of not only safeguarding human life, but also missing out on the contributions migrants can bring to the country, the bishop said.

“We simply cannot allow partisan division to continue to impede the needed interventions of government,” he said.

He implored national, state, and local governments to work together toward a humane response “to the unavoidable reality of migration” and what it has offers nations, including the United States, which has thrived and depended on past waves of immigration for its success.

“Whether Afghan, Ukrainian, or Venezuelan, Dreamer or undocumented farmworker, asylum-seeker, migrant, or refugee, all are imbued by God with an inviolable dignity,” he said. “This is the foundation of our church’s unwavering defense of human life in all its forms, contemplated in a special way during this Respect Life Month (in October).”

His reflection caps his term as chairman of the bishops’ migration committee, which will end in November.

“When Christ returns on the Last Day, his judgment will reveal the veracity of that notion. May each one of us — especially those bearing the burdens of leadership — be judged worthy to inherit God’s kingdom, having endeavored to build it on Earth,” Bishop Dorsonville said.

Read More Immigration & Migration

Pope Leo tells trafficking survivors God recognizes their ‘inestimable worth’ during Canary Islands visit

$70B immigration-enforcement funds exclude bishops-supported migrant protections

US bishops release prayer service commemorating immigrants, enslaved with call to action

Border bishops have ‘grave concerns’ about $72 billion immigration enforcement funding package

Study: Mass deportation has ‘chilling’ effect on labor market for immigrant, US-citizen workers

Proposed regulations would further restrict housing, work eligibility for migrants

Copyright © 2022 Catholic News Service/U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops

 Print