Study: Mass deportation has ‘chilling’ effect on labor market for immigrant, US-citizen workers

WASHINGTON (OSV News) — A mass deportation effort carried out by President Donald Trump’s administration could have a significant chilling effect on the economy and the labor market, including for U.S.-born workers, according to a new estimate.

The findings were in the working paper “Labor Market Impacts of ICE Activity in Trump 2.0,” released in early May by co-authors Chloe East, an associate professor of economics at the University of Colorado Boulder, and Elizabeth Cox, a research assistant with CU’s Institute for Behavioral Science. East and Cox compared U.S. regions that experienced “a large and sudden increase” in monthly ICE arrests between January 2025 and October 2025 with regions that did not, and found a “meaningful chilling effect” on the labor markets in the areas that had the surges.

“We show that heightened ICE activity is harming the labor market overall, and we find no evidence that it is benefiting U.S.-born workers,” East said in a statement. “If anything, job opportunities for U.S.-born workers are going down as a result.”

No U.S. national survey asks for immigration status, so the economists used a proxy model to estimate populations of unauthorized immigrants, they said. Using that model, East and Cox found that, on average, in a region that had experienced an ICE surge, 4% fewer “likely undocumented” immigrants remaining in the community reported working in the previous week.

J. Kevin Appleby, senior fellow for policy at the Center for Migration Studies of New York and the former director of migration policy for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, told OSV News the CU Boulder research shows that “while it may seem counterintuitive to some, undocumented immigrants working in certain industries stimulate growth in the economy, thus generating jobs in related occupations.”

“And studies have shown that most U.S. citizens shy away from jobs immigrants perform,” he said. “As a result, mass deportations can depress the economy and increase prices by shrinking the labor force.”

The researchers also found no evidence that employers increased wages to attract U.S.-born workers for roles previously filled by undocumented immigrants, or that U.S.-citizen workers had more job opportunities after the ICE enforcement surges.

On average, it found, in regions that had an ICE surge, 1.3% fewer U.S.-born males with a high school degree or less had jobs.

“There is a common narrative out there that mass deportations will free up job opportunities for U.S.-born workers, but numerous studies, including ours, have shown that is false,” East said. “If a construction company can’t find laborers, they’re going to take on less work and hire fewer people overall.”

The study found this impact was particularly significant in the agriculture, manufacturing and construction sectors.

Clayton Sinyai, a labor adviser for the Catholic Labor Network, told OSV News, “Mass deportation of immigrants living in our midst isn’t just cruel — it actually reduces job opportunities for native born workers.”

“That’s why the Church and the AFL-CIO agree that any solution to the challenges of immigration must include a path to citizenship for undocumented workers who have otherwise obeyed the law and contributed to our community,” he said.

Aimee Shelide Mayer, that group’s executive director, added that “Catholic social teaching insists that every worker is a human person with dignity, not simply a cog in the wheel to be discarded when politically convenient.”

“The evidence increasingly shows that mass deportation policies do not strengthen working families; they disrupt local economies, shrink the labor force, and can harm both immigrant and U.S.-born workers alike, especially in industries already facing labor shortages,” Shelide Mayer told OSV News. “A just immigration approach must uphold the rule of law while also recognizing the deep contributions immigrant workers make to our communities and creating realistic pathways for long-term, law-abiding workers to remain with their families and participate fully in the common good.”

Catholic social teaching on immigration balances three interrelated principles — the right of persons to migrate in order to sustain their lives and those of their families; the right of a country to regulate its borders and control immigration; and a nation’s duty to regulate its borders with justice and mercy.

“The moral issue here is that while immigrants help us economically, we are happy to scapegoat them, divide their families, and accept their sweat equity at very low wages,” Appleby added. “As a nation, we need to acknowledge this contradiction and provide them with legal protection.”

Read More Immigration and Migration

Religious, civic leaders join Pope Leo for Liberty Medal award ceremony

Catholic Review Media brings home 82 awards from journalism competitions for 2025 work

Radio Interview: From father to son

World’s conflicts are ‘fed’ more readily than people, Pope Leo XIV says

Movie Review: ‘Toy Story 5’

Not to Burst Your Balloon

Copyright © 2026 OSV News

 Print